Oh, I'm actually with you on this as well. Such a lovely image. And yes, I totally understand that some connection of flesh is probably necessary to have the whole spectacle make sense.
I have a big fantasy (mostly unrealized) about getting spanked in front of others. The public humiliation of being chastised while other watch your regret and tears. Maybe some feel sympathy, maybe others experience satisfaction in seeing just deserts dished out.
All of it part of the drama and so immensely satisfying in the mind.